Updated on: July 28, 2025
Introduction
Running a private practice involves more than clinical expertise—it demands strategic business decisions. One key choice is whether to accept insurance: should you become an in-network provider (i.e., get paneled or credentialed) or remain out-of-network/self-pay only? This decision shapes your income structure, client base, marketing approach, administrative tasks, and ultimately, your practice mission.
In this blog, we explore the core considerations, benefits, drawbacks, and practical guidance to help mental health professionals decide whether getting paneled with insurance is the right move for them.
What Is an Insurance Panel?
An insurance panel consists of healthcare providers credentialed with a specific insurer. In-network clinicians agree to pre-negotiated fee schedules and follow the insurer’s policies on billing, documentation, session modalities, and case requirements.
Patients can seek providers listed in their insurer’s directory and pay little or nothing upfront, while the provider bills the insurer directly.
Choices for Accepting Insurance
1. Get Credentialed (In-Network Provider)
You apply to join specific insurance panels via a formal credentialing process. Once approved, you’re paid directly by the insurer for covered sessions.
2. Out-of-Network / Self-Pay
You bill clients directly and may supply them with superbills—itemized invoices that they can submit to their insurer for reimbursement themselves. You receive payment upfront from the client.
3. Hybrid Model (Dual)
Combine both: accept insurance for in-network patients and offer private pay or superbills for others, giving you maximum flexibility.
Benefits of Joining Insurance Panels
1. Access to a Larger, More Diverse Client Base
Patients frequently search provider directories filtered by insurance. Accepting insurance dramatically improves visibility and referral potential. It also enables serving low- and moderate-income clients who cannot afford high out-of-pocket rates.
2. Built-In Referral Flow
Insurance companies, primary care providers, and employee assistance programs (EAPs) often refer to in-network providers—a passive but potent source of new clients.
3. Steadier Caseload & Improved Retention
Since clients may face minimal costs per session and plans sometimes authorize multiple visits, caseloads tend to remain stable over time.
4. Enhanced Credibility and Marketing Advantage
Being credentialed signals legitimacy to potential clients and referrers. This is especially valuable for newly-licensed clinicians.
5. Lower Marketing and Networking Burden
With incoming referrals via insurers, you can spend less time marketing and more time delivering care.
Drawbacks of Joining Insurance Panels
1. Lower Reimbursement Rates
In-network rates are lower than private pay—commonly $50–$100/session depending on geography, service codes, and payer. Some panels may pay less than Medicare rates.
2. Administrative Load & Delayed Payments
Credentialing takes months, often 3–6 months or longer, requiring a substantial amount of paperwork and verification. After joining, providers must submit claims, manage denials, and wait weeks for reimbursements.
3. Documentation Requirements & Insurer Oversight
Insurers may require diagnostic codes, treatment justifications, progress notes, prior authorizations, and occasional audits—adding more paperwork and reducing clinical autonomy.
4. Restrictions and Rigidity
Insurers often limit CPT codes, modalities, session length, frequency, and diagnostic categories—restricting flexibility in care delivery.
5. Risk of Burnout and Overload
A sudden flood of referrals from multiple panels can lead to scheduling pressure and provider fatigue if capacity isn’t managed well.
Pros & Cons: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | In-Network (Paneled) | Self-Pay / Out-of-Network |
|---|---|---|
| Client access | Higher via insurer directories & referrals | Limited to your marketing/network |
| Reimbursement rate | Lower, set by payer | Full fee, private negotiation |
| Payment timing | Often delayed (claim process) | Immediate (paid at session) |
| Administrative burden | High: applications, claims, audits | Low: minimal paperwork, optional superbills |
| Flexibility in care | Bound by insurer rules | Full control over treatment and scheduling |
| Client privacy | Insurer receives data | Client health info remains private |
| Caseload stability | Generally steadier | More variability depending on marketing |
When Does Credentialing Make Sense?
Credentialing is often the right move when:
- You’re building a new practice and want to attract clients through insurer referrals.
- You aim to serve individuals who rely on insurance to afford care.
- You’re comfortable managing billing tasks and claims.
- You’re willing to accept lower rates in exchange for volume and consistency.
- You want credibility and visibility in regional or national insurer directories.
When Might Self-Pay or Hybrid Models Work Better?
Consider self-pay or a hybrid model when:
- You already have a solid referral network or marketing strategy.
- You prefer higher earnings per client, more flexibility, and reduced bureaucracy.
- You value client privacy and autonomy over session frequency, duration, and modality.
- You’re willing to educate clients about using superbills or reimbursement options.
How to Get Paneled: Step-by-Step Roadmap
1. Organize Your Credentials
Collect your license, National Provider Identifier (NPI), liability insurance, resume, and business details.
2. Create a CAQH Profile
Set up your profile on the Council for Affordable Quality Healthcare. Insurers use this to verify credentials.
3. Choose Insurance Companies
Decide which panels to join—consider both national (Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare) and regional providers, including Medicaid if relevant.
4. Submit Applications
Apply directly to insurers or use credentialing services. Each application requires accuracy and timely follow-up.
5. Review and Sign Contracts
Once approved, carefully evaluate and sign contracts—pay special attention to reimbursement rates, session limits, and documentation expectations.
6. Market Your In-Network Status
Update your website, business listings, and practice materials to reflect accepted insurances.
Onboarding as an In-Network Provider
After you’re paneled:
- Verify coverage before each session.
- Submit claims promptly using EHR or billing software.
- Track reimbursements and follow up on unpaid claims.
- Document sessions in accordance with payer guidelines.
- Stay current with changes in codes, policy, and renewals.
Helpful Charts to Include in Your Blog
1. Decision Flowchart: Should You Accept Insurance?
Visualize yes/no paths based on goals, income needs, admin tolerance, and client accessibility.
2. Bar Chart: Reimbursement Rate Comparison
Compare in-network vs. private pay rates for 50-minute therapy sessions across several states.
3. Timeline: Credentialing Process
Map out time estimates from CAQH profile setup to first reimbursement—often 60–180 days.
4. Worksheet: Practice Fit Matrix
List factors like income, admin capacity, and target population to help clinicians self-evaluate.
Addressing Common Misconceptions
“Only new therapists need insurance.”
False—many seasoned therapists accept insurance to diversify income and client flow.
“The process is too complicated.”
It is time-consuming, but credentialing services, consultants, and tools can reduce the burden.
“Insurers pay too little to be worthwhile.”
This depends on location, volume, and your hourly rate. A well-managed in-network practice can still be highly profitable.
Eight Guiding Questions to Ask Yourself
- What is my ideal income per month?
- Am I willing to sacrifice some per-session rate for consistent volume?
- Do I have the administrative tools or help to manage billing?
- Is my target clientele insured, and do they seek in-network providers?
- How do I feel about potential oversight and documentation reviews?
- Can I comfortably handle 3–6 months of waiting during the credentialing process?
- Will accepting insurance help grow my business faster?
- Would a hybrid model balance both my financial and clinical goals?
Example Scenarios
New Clinician in Urban Area
Struggles to find private pay clients. Wants a full caseload. Insurance panels offer steady referrals. In-network makes sense.
Established Therapist in Rural Area
Has strong word-of-mouth referrals. Prefers minimal paperwork. Values flexibility. Self-pay or hybrid model works better.
Conclusion
The decision to accept insurance—and which insurance plans to work with—is one of the most important strategic choices you’ll make in private practice. It affects your income, clientele, workload, flexibility, and sustainability.
If you want predictable volume, exposure to a broader population, and fewer marketing demands, getting paneled could be the right move. If you want more clinical control, faster cash flow, and higher per-session earnings, self-pay may suit you better. Many providers find a hybrid model offers the best of both worlds.
Whichever route you take, ensure it aligns with your mission, lifestyle, and practice vision. Take time to map your goals, evaluate your local market, and plan your operations accordingly.
Struggling to decide if insurance paneling is right for your practice?
Experience seamless, AI-powered documentation—join DocScrib today and book your free demo to optimize your billing and clinical workflow.