Introduction
AI-powered scribe systems are revolutionizing clinical documentation — but how do you ensure they truly meet quality standards? Leading healthcare innovators like Soaper, SOAP Note AI, and Doximity are now turning to standardized validation methods like PDQI‑9 and DeepScore to measure note performance note.soaper.ai+15aijourn.com+15opmed.doximity.com+15arxiv.org+1arxiv.org+1.
1. Why Traditional Accuracy Isn’t Enough
Transcription accuracy (e.g., word error rate) only tells part of the story. Notes must also be complete, clear, consistent, and clinically suitable. Failure in any dimension can introduce risk. For example, PDQI‑9 and DeepScore both assess nuanced criteria like “Organizedness,” “Clarity,” and “Usefulness” .
2. Introducing PDQI‑9
The Physician Documentation Quality Instrument (PDQI‑9) scores notes across 9 dimensions:
-
Accuracy
-
Thoroughness
-
Clarity
-
Usefulness, etc.
A new open-source evaluation tool now lets providers upload AI notes and receive objective scores — plus determine whether the note feels human- or AI-generated arxiv.org+7arxiv.org+7revmaxx.co+7.
3. What DeepScore Brings to the Table
DeepScore is a composite quality index leveraging machine learning to assess note quality across clinical use cases. First introduced by DeepScribe, it provides:
-
A quantitative overall quality score
-
Breakdown of submetrics (completeness, coherence, etc.)
-
Continuous monitoring for ongoing improvements arxiv.orgsoapnote.ai.
4. Best Practices for AI Note Evaluation
-
Baseline Comparison – Run human vs AI-generated notes through PDQI‑9/DeepScore.
-
Multi-Specialty Sampling – Test a variety: primary care, psych, cardiology.
-
User-Driven Thresholds – Set minimum standards for deployment readiness.
-
Regular Re-Evaluation – Monthly audits post-implementation to catch drift.
5. Why It Matters for DocScrib
-
Builds Trust: Clinicians & compliance teams want data, not promises.
-
Demonstrates ROI: Improved scores = fewer edits, less time spent.
-
Prepares Providers: Empower providers to run their own audits easily.
6. Implementation: A Step‑By‑Step Guide
-
Step 1: Export sample AI-generated notes—across specialties.
-
Step 2: Score notes using PDQI‑9 (via open-source tool) and compute DeepScore.
-
Step 3: Share visual report: note quality vs. baseline.
-
Step 4: Identify weaknesses (e.g., lack of clarity, missed info).
-
Step 5: Adjust DocScrib prompts/templates, retrain the model, and re‑audit.
-
Step 6: Repeat quarterly to maintain high standards.
Conclusion
As AI scribes evolve, evaluation frameworks like PDQI‑9 and DeepScore are critical for ensuring quality, clinician confidence, and measurable impact. At DocScrib, we support data-driven deployment—helping your team deploy safely, effectively, and confidently.